Appealing Latvian citizenship refusal
March 3, 2018
Latvian citizenship application can be refused by the OCMA (Office of Citizenship and Migration Affairs of Latvia) for many reasons. In this article, we will focus on matters where citizenship is sought under the category of “Latvian exiles” or “Latvians and Livs”.
Finding of facts in matters of Latvian citizenship
Application for Latvian citizenship must be substantiated with many documents confirming certain facts such as, for example, kinship between the applicant and his/her Latvian ancestors, facts of holding Latvian citizenship by the ancestors prior to 1940, facts of ancestors’ residence in the territory of Latvia in 1881 or later, etc. Considering how old these records are and the circumstances under which people have fled Latvia it is no surprise that some records are missing or were destroyed during war time, or simply contain contradictory information.
Very common is difference in the vital records about oneself. For instance, in pre-war archive records a person’s date of birth is different as compared to the documents issued after the war, or a person has changed his/her name (without any records to be found of the legal change) while in evacuation during war time at another country, etc. All these differences in the records or undocumented changes may lead to the refusal of Latvian citizenship application.
In our practice, we deal with such cases on a regular basis. For example, our client applied for Latvian citizenship on the grounds that his father used to hold Latvian citizenship prior to 1940 and fled Latvia due to occupation regime. Formally our client was eligible for Latvian citizenship, but his father’s date of birth specified in the pre-war documents was different from the birth date specified in the documents that confirmed kinship between the client and his father. Even though it was obvious that the above documents mention one and the same person, the OCMA treated the documents as if they relate to two different persons due to difference in the birth dates, and eventually refused the citizenship application. Only in the court could we establish that the above documents in fact relate to one and the same person.
Citizenship may be refused for other reasons, too. For instance, applicant may be sure that he/she meets the eligibility criteria, whilst OCMA believes that the applicant’s case is not the one entitling him/her to the citizenship under the current Latvian laws. Such refusals concern the correct interpretation and application of the Citizenship Law of Latvia. Where a dispute arises between the applicant and the OCMA regarding the interpretation of the law, the case may be referred to the court.
Appealing against the decision of the OCMA
So, what to do if your application for Latvian citizenship has been refused due to inaccuracies in the submitted documents or incorrect interpretation and application of the Citizenship law?
According to Latvian laws, the decision of the OCMA can be disputed to the head of OCMA, and then appealed to the court. The application for disputing of the OCMA decision may be lodged within 1 month after entry into force thereof. If the head of OCMA did not change the decision, then it can be appealed to the court within 1 month.
Initiation of the appellate procedure makes it possible for the client to establish certain facts in the court and prove the eligibility for Latvian citizenship. If the documents submitted to the OCMA along with the application contain inaccurate information, the facts required for successful application may be established by the court on the ground of the existing indirect evidences, witness statements, etc. The same relates to the cases concerning Citizenship law interpretation: the applicant gets the chance to argue his/her case in the court and prove that interpretation of the Citizenship law given by the OCMA is incorrect.
Therefore, even if the citizenship application is refused, there is a chance to confirm eligibility in the court by means of appealing the decision of the Office of Citizenship and Migration Affairs of Latvia.
SUBMIT YOUR QUESTIONS
Belyaev & Belyaev law firm specialises in matters concerning citizenship refusals and disputes with the OCMA. If for any reasons, you have been refused Latvian citizenship, apply for consultation at Belyaev & Belyaev law firm. We will consider the grounds of the refusal and advise on possibilities for appealing the OCMA decision, as well as represent your interests in the courts of Latvia.
GET IN TOUCH WITH US
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again!